Lighthouse Hotel
Social, colorful, LGBTQ-welcoming historic inn. Think poolside mojitos, live music on Saturday mornings, and neighbors with six-toed cats across the street.
Book direct through the official website for the best perks — up to 30% off plus a $25 resort credit at time of research
Why It Matters
Originally home to Isabel, Ernest Hemingway's mistress and his wife's seamstress, the property has serious Old Town bones. It was also one of Key West's pioneering LGBTQ guesthouses — and gold nuggets were reportedly discovered on the grounds. Now part of the Key West Historic Inns Collection and a member of Small Luxury Hotels of the World.
A loose collection of mid-1800s buildings spanning half a city block in the heart of Old Town Key West — directly across the street from the Hemingway Home and 200 feet from the actual lighthouse. The grounds ramble in the best way: a heated pool surrounded by tropical gardens, an old banyan tree, brick paths, and shaded nooks. Rooms lean contemporary-classic with tropical prints, vintage-inspired furniture, and Samsung HD TVs. But the real draw is the scene — this place is colorful, social, and proudly inclusive, with a history as a pioneering LGBTQ guesthouse adding an extra layer of character.
Where You'll Stay
7 room types available
Classic King
A plush king bed in a thoughtfully designed space. Size varies widely (175–425 sq ft) depending on the specific unit, so it pays to ask at booking which building your room is in.
1 KingHemingway King Suite
The flagship room. At 720 sq ft over two stories, it has a full kitchen, separate living and dining areas, a wrap-around balcony overlooking Whitehead Street and the Hemingway House, and a deep soaking tub. This is the room for a honeymoon or a serious splurge — and the views justify it.
1 KingKing Mobility
The accessible option, with an adapted bathroom featuring grab bars and a removable shower head. Same island-chic style as the rest of the property.
1 King
One Bedroom Suite
A king bed with a separate living area — more room to spread out than the standard rooms. A solid step up for couples who want some breathing space.
1 KingSingle Queen
The entry-level room. Compact and island-chic, with one queen bed and a thoughtful layout. At 170–240 sq ft, it is on the smaller side — fine for a couple who plans to spend most of their time at the pool or exploring Old Town.
1 QueenTwo Bedroom Loft Suite
A two-story loft layout with a king on one level and a queen on another. The vertical layout is distinctive — more character than a typical two-bed hotel room. Sleeps up to four.
1 King + 1 QueenTwo Queens
Two queen beds in a welcoming layout — the right call for friend groups or families. At 325–475 sq ft it offers considerably more breathing room than the Single Queen.
2 QueensThe Property
Eat & Drink
1 venue on property
Restaurant
Spa & Wellness
Treatment Menu
On Property
How you'll actually spend your days.
The hotel partners with Island Safari Rentals to offer cruiser bikes, e-bikes, scooters, and golf carts. Arrange via QR code on property signage or at the front desk.
The property's concierge, Jenny Berube, can design custom itineraries for guests — recommendations, reservations, and local intel.
Every Saturday from 9–11 AM, a resident fiddler or clarinetist performs poolside during breakfast. A genuinely nice touch — sip a mimosa and ease into the day.
Complimentary continental breakfast served poolside at Isabel's daily from 8–10 AM. Fresh fruit, pastries, coffee, tea, and grab-and-go items. The hotel also runs a filtered water station and all-day coffee and tea service.
Every guest receives two welcome cocktails redeemable at Isabel's poolside bar — signature mojitos or whatever you feel like.
Interactive 3D virtual tour of the property available online — useful for pre-arrival planning and room selection.
Complimentary yoga mats available for guest use.
Amenities & Practical Info
The details that matter for planning.
In-room WiFi included at 50+ Mbps speeds across the property.
Filtered water station for refilling reusable bottles. Coffee and tea service available all day poolside.
Rambling grounds with lush tropical gardens, an old banyan tree, brick paths, and shaded seating areas throughout the half-block property.
Pets are welcome. Fee is $50/night. No size restrictions mentioned.
The heart of the property. Open daily 8 AM–10 PM, with sun loungers and direct access to Isabel's bar. Surrounded by tropical gardens and an old banyan tree.
In-room safes available in all guestrooms.
Premium bedding in all rooms.
Samsung HD flat-screen televisions with satellite channels in all rooms.
Atelier Bloem toiletries provided in all bathrooms.
Private parking available on-site at $20/day. No reservation required.
There is no on-site gym or spa. For guests who need these, off-property options in Key West are available.
BUILD YOUR LIGHTHOUSE HOTEL - KEY WEST HISTORIC INNS PLAN
Rooms, dining, spa, and resort experiences — organized into one trip plan.
Start Planning